Compare car insurance companies head-to-head
Pick any two of the 28 insurers we review and see them set against each other on the same six categories — price, claims, complaints, financial strength, discounts, and digital tools — with every gap spelled out and every figure sourced. 359 pairings, all of them.
Build a comparison
Choose two insurers and we’ll take you straight to the breakdown.
Most-compared pairings
The matchups drivers actually search for, each with extra context on why these two get compared in the first place.
Geico vs ProgressiveToo close to call on our scoringGeico vs State FarmToo close to call on our scoringAllstate vs State FarmState Farm ahead by 0.9 on our scoreAllstate vs ProgressiveProgressive ahead by 0.7 on our scoreGeico vs USAAToo close to call on our scoringProgressive vs State FarmToo close to call on our scoringState Farm vs USAAToo close to call on our scoringErie vs State FarmToo close to call on our scoringAmica vs State FarmState Farm ahead by 0.6 on our scoreGeico vs Liberty MutualToo close to call on our scoring
Every comparison
All 359 pairings. Each pair has one page, listed here under whichever insurer comes first alphabetically — so if you don’t see a matchup under one company, look under the other.
Allstate
- vs American Family
- vs Amica
- vs Auto-Owners
- vs Chubb
- vs Clearcover
- vs COUNTRY Financial
- vs Elephant
- vs Erie
- vs Farmers
- vs Geico
- vs The Hanover
- vs Kemper
- vs Lemonade
- vs Liberty Mutual
- vs MAPFRE
- vs Mercury
- vs Nationwide
- vs NJM
- vs Plymouth Rock
- vs Progressive
- vs Root
- vs Shelter
- vs State Farm
- vs Texas Farm Bureau
- vs The Hartford
- vs Travelers
- vs USAA
Comparing two is useful. Comparing fifty is better.
50+ insurers, about four minutes, free either way.